Argentina next best bet for Haitians as Chile tightens immigration controls

By September 4, 2018

Haitians emigrating to South America from their native country have traditionally chosen Chile as an adoptive home, based in part on its relative economic security. However, after President Sebastián Piñera revoked on-arrival tourist visas in April, the numbers have been dropping and those unable to stay in Chile have turned their gaze to neighbouring country Argentina.

Right-wing Piñera’s decision in April had immediate results, and since May, more Haitians are leaving Chile than entering the country, Economia y Negocios explained.

For those who do not wish to return home, Argentina is their new prospect. General Director of Legal Technique at the National Migration Management Group, Diego Enriquez, told Economia y Negocios that there had been an explosion of Haitians attempting to enter the country as tourists. However, Argentine authorities have been turning them away for not meeting the conditions required for being a tourist.

“We ask them a few simple questions; where they’re going to stay, their flight ticket, if they have any funds or a credit card, or if they have any relations or someone they’re coming to see,” he explained. “Faced with this simple interrogation, they cannot respond. It’s clear that they’re coming to Argentina not for tourism purposes, but rather to settle down or something else.”

In the first seven months of 2018, there were 900 cases reported of Haitians attempting to enter Argentina, whereas throughout 2017 there were only 221.

Confronted with this influx of non-tourist Haitians, Argentina reinstated the requirement of a tourist entry visa for Haitians wanting to enter the country.

Bernardino Cárdenas, head of the Prefecture of the International Airport Police in Chile, explained to Economia y Negocios that the most common way for Haitians to enter Argentina from Chile is at the border crossing point Los Libertadores. 

Haitian emigration began in earnest after the devastating earthquake in 2010 which destroyed buildings and infrastructure, leaving thousands homeless and jobless. The Migration Policy Institute recorded that Chile awarded 300 temporary visas to Haitians in 2009, which grew to 8,900 in 2015 and 44,000 in 2016.

However, the UN reported that in 2016 Brazil was the country who welcomed the largest number of Haitians, totalling 67,000, with Chile seeing 18,000 Haitians entering the country and Argentina trailing behind at just 1,200.

HaitiLibre reported that the political system in Haiti does not create an environment that encourages young Haitians to remain in their native country. The Observatory of Haitian Youth commented to the Haitian news site on the President’s failure to address this issue.

“Since his ascension to the presidency, the Head of State Jovenel Moïse has never really addressed this problem in order to take special measures to remedy it. This complicit silence pushes the platform to believe that pushing young people out of the country is part of the current executive’s political strategy.”

However, the plight of Haitians attempting to create a better life elsewhere is hugely overshadowed by the mass exodus of Venezuelans fleeing their country due to severe shortages of basic goods such as food and medical supplies. Chile and Argentina are both much more welcoming to these immigrants than they are to Haitians, BBC Mundo noted. Both countries have relaxed their immigration laws for the Venezuelans but have applied restrictions for Haitians.

With refugee crises taking place in Myanmar, Syria and Venezuela, tremendous pressure is being placed on neighbouring countries and other nationalities are finding themselves placed firmly as a second priority.